Sunday 20 March 2011

Child care and early years education: the ideas of Susan Isaacs, Melanie Klein and Anna Freud

A historical survey of the development, and contestation, of the key person approach
This is an extract from a piece of research which I undertook a couple of years back. It is an attempt to describe how the key person approach developed through the ideas of Susan Isaacs, Melanie Klein and Anna Freud, and the significant contribution made by later practitioners and writers.

From the 1920s onwards, psychoanalytic thinking began to influence theory and practice in English nursery childcare, an attention to children’s emotional development which would eventually inform the development of the key person system.  Susan Isaacs’s Malting House School (open from 1924-1929) for children aged from 2 upwards provided the context for the development of some of the key ideas in the Kleinian school of psychoanalysis (Mitchell, 1986). Isaacs provided the children with an environment in which there were more opportunities for free play and fewer prohibitions, to enable “an all-round lessening of the degree of inhibition of children’s impulses" (Isaacs, quoted in Drummond: 2000). In this context, aspects of the child’s anxiety could be expressed symbolically, and this symbolisation was seen to support the child’s ego-development and the "greater dramatic vividness of … social and imaginative and intellectual life as a whole" (Isaacs, quoted in Drummond: 2000).

Thursday 3 March 2011

Isn’t good early education about the development of the whole child?

Emotional development and communication have been first among equals in the early years curriculum for many years. So I have not been too surprised to find that every time I am in a group discussing the future of Children’s Centres, or the EYFS, there is always a suggestion that these two areas should be prioritised.

It is easy to agree with that; but agreeing the practical steps to take is trickier. I start by being sceptical of attempts at the direct teaching of specific skills. We know, from many years of research, that children’s brains are magnificently fit for the purpose of learning language. Immersed in a sea of words and meanings, nearly all children will become communicators and listeners – the exception being the small proportion of children with a specific speech and language difficulty, who need specialist help.